Radio Nederland Wereldomroep

English > The State We're In > Themes

Forced abortions in China

by Dheera Sujan

19-12-2008

Listen to the audio fileFor decades, China has implemented a One Child policy, overturning hundreds of years of tradition which stressed the importance of large families, including several sons. It was a sign of tremendous political discipline that a mindset stretching back centuries could be overturned in just one generation.

Jin Yani and Yang Zhongchen
Jin Yani and her husband Yang Zhongchen
Urban families are restricted one child, rural families sometimes allowed two or for some ethnic groups, even three children. However in recent years, the policy has not been uniformly enforced. Wealthier couples who can pay the fines and penalties involved with having more than one child, do. Poorer families however don't have that option.

Thousands adopted
So in a culture that still values sons over daughters, girl infants (often the second daughters of rural families) are abandoned and adopted out of the country which allows a chance for couples to try for that much needed son. Although the slow trickle down of China's immense economic boom is slowing down the trend, China still provides thousands of babies - by far most of them girls, or handicapped children of both sexes - for the international adoption circuit every year.

The government claims that enforcing the One Child policy has been responsible for spreading the wealth, and that the country's limited resources would have had to feed 400 million more people had the policy not been implemented. Sometimes however the means justifying the end are particularly brutal.

Forced to abort
Local family planning agencies are responsible for keeping birth quotas low, and in some places their eagerness to meet their statistics over reach the actual policy. No case illustrates this more graphically that that of Jin Yani, young, recently married and happily expecting her first child.

Just days away from her due date, she was resting in the house of her mother-in-law one evening when a van pulled up outside their door. She was dragged outside, forced into the van and taken to the local family planning centre. Even eight years later, she sobs as she recounts what happened next:

"Someone said, ‘you have to come with us, who gave you permission to have a child'. After a while we stopped at a building that looked like a hospital. Later I learned it was the family planning centre. They dragged me inside and started to examine me. They wanted to give me an injection, but I refused. I got down on my knees and pleaded with them that I wanted to be a mother and keep my child. I said I was willing to pay, 10,000 or 20,000 Yuan, but they would not listen. Then two guys dragged me into a room, the equipment looked rather old and not very good. Some people who looked like doctors came in. They held me down and gave me an injection. I passed out." Her husband, Yang Zhongchen was away on business when his wife was taken away. On hearing what had happened, he rushed home, to find his wife in a shocking physical state:

"I could not have imagined that something like this was even possible. When I arrived at her bed side she was all blue and very weak. I said to them you have killed my baby, now don't kill my wife, do whatever it takes to keep her alive. The doctor told us that the dead baby wouldn't come out naturally. It was too big. They would have to use forceps to crush its head. Then they ripped it out of the womb by force. I don't like to think about it. Whenever I remember this, I am about to faint."

Yang Zhongchen and Jin Yani
Yang and Jin: don't understand why this happened to them
Greasing the wheels
Neither of them really understand why this happened to them. Perhaps it was because they married a year short of the legal marriageable age, or perhaps they hadn't filled out the requisite paperwork to have this child. It was something that Yang thought he could do after the birth of the baby, and in fact he had even taken out the local officials to dinner in the obligatory way to grease the wheels of the local bureaucracy, but now suspects that he simply had not paid a large enough bribe. So in effect, they were put through this ordeal because of a bureaucratic technicality.

Despite the one child policy, forced abortions are illegal in China, but there have been reported - and then hushed up - cases in scattered rural areas. Stories have emerged of women being physically forced to abort very late term pregnancies, of relatives of pregnant women being imprisoned and tortured until she accedes to an abortion. Activists who try to bring the subject to light are harassed or jailed and people are reluctant to discuss a subject that is close to taboo.

No apology
Jin Yani and Yang Zhongchen are unusual in that they decided to fight the authorities, to get them to answer for what they did. They have lost their business and their life savings in the monumental effort to take the local officials to court, but as yet, they have been offered neither compensation, nor apology. Their hopes of having a baby dim with every passing year, and they suspect that too much damage has been done to Jin Yani's body by the forced abortion for her to be able to conceive again. Yang Zhongchen sums up the many sided grief he and his wife must live with, perhaps for the rest of their lives:

"They took our family life. Look at us: We don't have a child, my wife is sick, we are no longer a normal family. And we didn't get justice..., no matter what the future holds for us, the shadows of the past can never be erased."

Back to the TSWI home page

 

Tags: abortion, adoption, China, One Child policy

Reaction(s):


François, 10-02-2009 - Netherlands

This article should be a wake up call for all pro-abortionists. Women on Waves and Planned Parenthood have been accused of funding and ignoring this kind of abuses because they support abortion at all costs. This is what would happen if as UNFPA and Planned Parenthood advocates, abortion were legalized in Africa, Asia and other developing countries. Where human rights are not respected abortion could become another weapon to use against the very women that the abortionists say they are protecting. What is important in human rights debates is to acknowledge that the message needs to be uniform, consistent, egalitarian but above all it should respect human dignity and place human life at the epitome of all human rights. Advocating for the destruction of some human beings in order to give other human beings their privacy or economic prosperity or education or spare them embarassment is definately the wrong approach. All human beings whether 2 seconds old or 100yrs old have a right to life. Whether women or men, disabled or able, sick or healthy, religious or secular no one should be denied life in order to improve the life of another. This why when we human beings try to tweak human populations we end up with disastrous consequences. The one child policy in China may look quite reasonable in reducing the population and saving costs to an uninformed observer. However in the province of Guandong for example it has led to a population ratio of 20 men for every 1 woman. This is but one of the unintended consequences that comes from us trying to play God with life. This starts with contraception, abortion, homosexuality and now with genetic manipulations. All these things are inter - related and can create conundrums for human society that we can barely imagine today.


layla, 22-12-2008 - usa

The story was absolutely horrific. It literally froze me on my seat when I heard it. It was one of those moments that I thought I cannot just shake my head and move on and I must do something. Can you provide more information about this couple? I can certainly donate money to their cause and I can try raising money for them. I can write to my elected officials in the congress and demand them to put pressure on China. I am sure there are things that ordinary concerned citizens of this country can do, so please provide more information.


jasmin, 21-12-2008 - India

How brutal is the bureaucracy of China! With all the scandels emerging in China, against the public health, I wonder, if it is fit for living! But then which place in the world is safe today! Your government, your family, your neighbouring countries, the MNC's, all have one agenda: snuff out the common man. The State We are in! I am depressed!


Give your reaction



Name
E-mail
Hide my email address
Show my email address
URL
City
Country
Comments
  Please type in the letters/numbers in the image below in order to prevent spam.
 
Send a copy of this message to my email address
This is a moderated forum. Reactions may be edited before they appear online.