Radio Nederland Wereldomroep

English > In-depth > The Research File

No salty solution to nuclear waste

by Thijs Westerbeek

23-04-2007

The salt mine at Gorleben

The salt mine at Gorleben,
across the border in Germany

Working in the salt mine at Gorleben

Click to hear the whole Research File programme

wma-camb-192.gifmp3-camb-192.gif

Salt domes are often seen as safe locations for the permanent storage of nuclear waste. However, recent research at Groningen University in the Netherlands has pointed out that radiation may have a catastrophic effect on the stability of these domes.

For a start, the rock salt is likely to degrade. Worse could happen at a later stage, with possible explosions and probable leakage of radiation into the environment.
 
Russian-born researcher Anton Victorovitz Sugonyaku is the author of the thesis about salt dome radiation hazards. He questions the feasibility of the entire concept of storing radioactive waste in these underground mountains of rock salt.
 
Dr Sugonyaku explains that they were formed eons ago and have never changed since. This apparent immunity to change has made them a prime candidate in the search for a safe nuclear waste storage location.

The idea is to drill a hole deep into the salt dome - we're talking hundreds of metres - and then lower containers with radioactive waste into the hole. Once enough containers have been stacked on top of each other, the hole will be filled with concrete, thus ensuring that no radiation ever escapes.
 
Not such a good idea after all
Until recently, this seemed to be an excellent idea. The waste would just sit deep underground forever, slowly burning off all radiation until it posed no threat anymore. The chance that future generations would accidentally stumble upon the containers were minute; they're just too deep down.

Furthermore, as salt domes were seen as among the most stable of geological formations, it seemed the perfect solution. Dr Sugonyaku's research has changed this perception.
 
Sodium chloride"Radiation definitely has an effect on salt," Anton Sugonyaku explains.

"It decomposes rock salt and transforms sodium chloride molecules into sodium and chlorine. Sodium is a metal, and chlorine is a vapour, and these elements are formed as small precipitates in the crystal lattice."

In layman's terms, the rock salt's crystal structure loses its integrity. Then, the story gets worse:

"If the radiation damage is sufficient there can be explosions, and it's even possible that radiation will leak to the surface."

The experiments
Conducting experiments which are supposed to mimic the exposure of rock salt to millennia of radiation will never be completely realistic. Dr Sugonyaku tried to get as close as possible, radiating salt crystals in his laboratory for several months. The radiation levels could be controlled, as well as the speed of the radiation and the temperature of the crystals.

The Borssele nuclear power plant in the Netherlands

The Borssele nuclear power plant in the Netherlands

All this makes the resulting data scientifically valid; the predictions stand. It leaves us with the question of whether salt domes are definitely not an option anymore when it comes to storing nuclear waste. Surprisingly, for Dr Sugonyaku, the answer is not an unequivocal 'No'.
 
"I think we should dig deeper, scientifically, we should search for materials that can be put in between the canisters and the natural rock salts. Natural rock salt is very sensitive to radiation, we know that, we have seen that, but we have found some materials , also sodium chloride materials, which are much less sensitive. For instance, sodium chloride doped with bromine or iodide could serve as a protective layer..."Conclusion
If salt domes are to be used as storage locations for nuclear waste, monitoring will be key. Rock salts may still be a viable option, but the original idea of just putting the waste deep into the ground and then basically forgetting about it is definitely out.

Tags: atomic, borssele, energy, gorleben, groningen, netherlands, nuclear, salt domes, sugonyaku

Reaction(s):


Joan , 30-04-2007 - UK

There might also be a problem resulting from acoustic mismatch between the crystalline structure of salt and concrete. Even a minor explosion in the salt crystals due to radiation induced decomposition could generate shock waves in the concrete which has relatively poor tensile properties.


Give your reaction



Name
E-mail
Hide my email address
Show my email address
URL
City
Country
Comments
  Please type in the letters/numbers in the image below in order to prevent spam.
 
Send a copy of this message to my email address
This is a moderated forum. Reactions may be edited before they appear online.