Radio Nederland Wereldomroep

English > Current Affairs > Archive by region > XXX notinuse Western Europe

Robert McCartney’s family deserves money from terrorist victim’s fund says EU

by Newsline and Kim Renfrew

11-05-2005

Simon-Coveney.jpg
MEP Simon Coveney

The family of a man murdered by a gang which included members of the terrorist Irish Republican Army (IRA) organisation deserve financial assistance, says the European Parliament.

Robert McCartney was killed on 30 January this year, in a fight outside Magennis’s bar in Belfast, on 30 January this year.  The brawl is believed to have started after alleged IRA members accused Mr McCartney’s friend Brendan Devine of making obscene gestures to their female companion. When Mr Devine did not accept the accusation or apologise, the fight began and both men were stabbed; Mr Devine survived the attack, but Mr McCartney died of his wounds the following morning.

Fear of retribution
Although more than 70 bystanders were present in the bar that evening, not one witness has come forward. Mr McCartney’s sisters - as well as those who support them in their fight to bring their brother’s killers to justice - say this is because many people fear retribution from the paramilitary organisation. As Simon Coveney, an Irish Fine Gael MEP who supports the McCartneys, points out:

wma-1.jpg real-k1.jpg
Click to listen to the interview with Simon Coveney
“After the murder, nobody was allowed to call an ambulance, […] There was a clinical clean-up operation undertaken, again by a group of IRA members. Since then, because fear of coming forward, nobody has come before the police service of Northern Ireland to give evidence.”



Stopping short
While the McCartney family mounted a very public justice campaign, bringing on board assistance from London and Washington, the IRA responded by offering to shoot those responsible. Meanwhile, the organisation’s political wing Sinn Fein, has skirted around the issue, suspending party members but always stopping short of actually telling witnesses to go to the police.

"Sinn Fein talk a lot about how they support the McCartney family and so on, but unfortunately we still haven’t got anybody coming forward giving hard evidence, despite the fact that there were up to 70 people there on the night,” Euro MEP Simon Coveney
But now Strasbourg says the dead man’s family should be granted money from a one million euro fund intended for victims of terrorism. A vote on 10 May decided 555 to four (with 48 abstentions) to urge the European Commission to provide financial support for the family. This will give a boost to the funds they need to proceed with a civil case against the killers, should a criminal case not see the light of day. The European Parliament’s President Josep Borrell said he hoped the decision would help to break the ‘wall of silence’ surrounding the case.

Terrorist killing
Mr Coveney adds that, although he doesn’t think this was strictly a political killing, he says it nevertheless qualifies as a terrorist one, and is eligible for the EC money:

“I don’t think this was a politically-motivated murder. What seems to have happened was that a group of IRA members were coming home after a Republican rally; they were in a bar drinking, and there was an argument. It seems then that the order was given to take somebody outside and to butcher them. You have organisation here by the IRA – during and following this murder. Even though it wasn’t a politically motivated one to begin with, it was certainly a murder carried out by a terrorist organisation. From that point of view, it certainly qualifies for me as a terrorist murder.”

Sinn Fein must take responsibility
And, says Mr Coveney, Sinn Fein – with two MEPs, who both voted against the motion – has particular responsibility in helping to resolve this issue:

“Although many people have come forward, others have not, particularly some who may have been directly involved in Robert's murder. In my view these people must give a full account through whatever conduit they choose,” Sinn Fein President Gerry Adams
“The only political party that has the power to unlock this case is Sinn Fein.  Both Sinn Fein and the IRA need to reassure people that if they come forward in this case, and give evidence which leads to a conviction, they will not be victims themselves in the future. That’s why people like myself have continued to pile as much pressure as we can on Sinn Fein to actually make that happen. If there is to be finality to this case, the only way it’ll happen is if both the IRA and their political representatives, Sinn Fein, actually insist on people coming forward to give evidence.”