Radio Nederland Wereldomroep

by Alexander Weissink*

05-05-2009

The government's plan to destroy all of Egypt's pigs led to fierce protest from the country's predominately Christian pig farmers. The measure is an attempt by the Egyptian government to prevent Mexican flu from breaking out in Egypt. The country is still dealing with cases of Avian flu.

Egyptian pig farmers"We threw pig manure at them", laughs Peter, a 20-year-old waste collector in the working-class neighbourhood of Ezbet el-Nakhl, in Cairo's north end.

By "them" he means the veterinary authorities who came four days ago to inspect the pig farms. They will return with riot police to destroy the pigs tomorrow. But Peter does not expect any new confrontations to take place. "We have given up. They'll win regardless."

Fighting
Elsewhere in Egypt, the last few days have seen heavy fighting breaking out between the pig farmers and riot police. On Sunday, police used tear gas and allegedly fired rubber bullets in an attempt to break up a demonstration by farmers.

The government's decision to destroy Egypt's estimated 300,000 pigs has led to fierce protest from pig farmers. They see it as yet another form of discrimination against the Coptic Orthodox Christian community, which accounts for approximately 10% of Egypt's population.

Egypt's Muslim majority is strongly in favour of the cull as pigs are viewed by Muslims as unclean animals. Imams on television are appealing to the government to completely ban the keeping of pigs once and for all.

Egyptian pig farmersCompensation
All pigs in Egypt must be destroyed within three weeks. The government has set aside 4 million euros in compensation money.

It is unclear, however, how the money will be paid out, making pig farmers wonder if it they will receive compensation at all.

The government has disregarded the wish of many Egyptian Muslims to ban pig farming in the future. The Ministry of Agriculture has announced that in two years, land for new pig farms will be allocated outside of the city, at the edge of the desert.

The World Health Organisation has criticised the pig cull in Egypt. There have been no cases of Mexican flu in Egypt as yet. Moreover, there is no evidence showing that pigs can transmit the virus to humans, making a cull unnecessary.

Avian flu
It seems that the Egyptian government, however, does not want to leave anything to chance. Two years ago, the government responded too slowly to an outbreak of avian flu which, in turn, led to the spread of the virus - a virus they are still combating to this day.

Three new avian flu fatalities have been reported in the past month. In total, 26 people have died from avian flu, making Egypt the hardest hit country outside of Asia.

For the time being, avian flu (H5N1) is a bigger problem in Egypt than Mexican flu (H1N1). Although officially banned, people are still keeping chickens, ducks, geese and pigeons in populated areas, in both rural and urban areas. It is mostly young women who feed the fowl, that contract the disease.

Hygiene
The Egyptian government says the slaughter of the country's pigs is not only a preventative measure against Mexican flu, but also a more general health safety measure. "Mexican flu is a good reason to stop the very unhygienic conditions in densely populated areas", said a spokesperson for the Ministry of Health and Population.

Most pig farms are located on the rubbish heaps of Egypt's shantytowns, which is why they are often seen as hotbeds of disease.

Rubbish heaps
The current system allows for the recycling of much of Egypt's organic waste. Entire families work on the rubbish heaps, picking out the organic waste to feed to the pigs. The pig farmers predict that the culling of pigs will lead to an accumulation of rotting refuse. "I won't collect rubbish any longer if I can't feed it to the pigs", says 15-year-old Bishoi, as he lets a large bag of rubbish fall from his donkey cart to the ground. "What am I supposed to do with it?"

RNW Translation (sr)

Tags: avian flu, Coptic Orthodox Christians, Egypt, mexican flu, Muslims, pigs, swine flu, World Health Organisation

Reaction(s):


Steve, 07-05-2009 - USA

X, I agree they should move these farms out of urban areas because of their potential to spread disease, but how is killing all of the animals a means to accomplishing this? On top of that they are only paying them 13 EUR per animal.


X, 06-05-2009 - Egypt

I would like to comment on Steve's response. I don't think you have ever visited Egypt or know anything about the Christian minority in Egypt... If you have ever known anything about Egypt you would have said that the Egyptian gov. should have done those actions even if swine flu wasn't there. One other correction, Muslims are prohibited to eat pork, but they are not ordered to kill pigs. Pigs are creatures created by God and no Muslim could claim that there is a religious order to kill them. So let's not involve religion in this...


Steve, 06-05-2009 - USA

"The measure is an attempt by the Egyptian government to prevent Mexican flu from breaking out in Egypt." It is documented that this flu is not transferred through pork. This is the Egyptian government's attempt to kick the Christian minority when no one is looking. 12 Euros per pig, now that is fair compensation.


Give your reaction



Name
E-mail
Hide my email address
Show my email address
URL
City
Country
Comments
  Please type in the letters/numbers in the image below in order to prevent spam.
 
Send a copy of this message to my email address
This is a moderated forum. Reactions may be edited before they appear online.