Radio Nederland Wereldomroep

English > Current Affairs > Archive by region > Europe

Gergiev: ambassador for empathy?

By Fiona Campbell and Iain Macintyre

21-08-2008

The renowned Ossetian-born Russian conductor Valery Gergiev returns to South Ossetia to bring a message of peace and support to his homeland. He's giving a concert in the open air market in the centre of Tskhinvali, a city heavily damaged during the intense fighting.

Valery Gergiev
Valery Gergiev © Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra


Gergiev was born in Moscow of Ossetian parents and grew up in Vladikavkaz, the capital of the Russian province of North Ossetia.

He is chief conductor of the London Symphony Orchestra and is also artistic director of the Mariinsky Theatre in St Petersburg. They are the musicians who will be taking the stage tonight.

The conductor says his decision to stage a concert was motivated by a wish to bring people together, to bring about reconciliation. Last year he spoke to Radio Netherlands Worldwide about the power of music in the face of conflict:

"The world needs this peace and musicians can make these kind of statements. They can also be a very good example for many politicians, the people who are responsible.... Peace is exactly what everyone believes in. If we think of tomorrow or the day after tomorrow, or especially if we think of our children." Nevertheless, he does not try to hide his national loyalty in the face of this conflict:

"One thing I do know. When a thousand or 12 hundred people are killed, many of them peacefully asleep in their beds, the world cannot shut its eyes to the fact."Jan Raes is director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra where Gergiev conducted for 13 years. The works which will be heard on Thursday evening are Shostakovitch's seventh symphony and Tchaikovksy's sixth. What makes this appropriate music to perform in the midst of the Georgia conflict and will anyone be listening?

Jan Raes:
"Shostakovitch's seventh is a really symbolic piece to bring people some hope. And the Tchaikovsky is for many people in the world, especially in Russia maybe, a sort of farewell piece. It's about death, it's the last symphony of Tchaikovsky... and everybody knows this slow movement. And it has some religious power maybe for these people... to bring people together when they are suffering."Music and politics is a notoriously dangerous mix. And Gergiev is known for his pro-Russian views. He's a friend of Vladimir Putin, after all. Aren't people bound to question his motives?

Jan Raes:
"He is a great musician and, of course, with all his connections, he will bring people together. I think that's his main goal. But his first reaction is very emotional because he grew up in this region.... Gergiev is speaking with his wife and children Ossetian and not Russian. So it's very close for him - emotionally - and I think it's maybe for him very important to create some bridges and to be an ambassador for empathy."

Music is meant to be a healing thing, a peaceful thing, so when someone is so closely involved with the crisis and has strong personal viewpoints, can the orchestra play there on a neutral basis?

Jan Raes:
"No, I think it's impossible to be neutral, it's impossible to be objective, it's always emotional. Everybody has his history. But it's not the first time Russians use music on these difficult moments. I think Gergiev and many colleagues are adult enough to know it's not the real solution for all these incredible problems."

 

Tags: Jan Raes, London Symphony Orchestra, Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra, South Ossetia, Valery Gergiev, Vladimir Putin

Reaction(s):


Kelly L. Norman, sirpaulfan@comcast.net, 30-08-2008 - USA

Actually, the Tskhinvali concert and Gergiev's comments are getting *a lot* of press over here, and it's getting some people to say...."Oh, you mean there's another side to this?" Duh. I've been very distraught about the military-sounding and literally untrue statements he was making 9the Russian prosecuter's number about the dead in Ossetia...the highest number has been 136, and Gergiev keeps going around saying 1500! 2000! But Jan Raes' comments hear make me understand a little bit better. I wish my country would butt out, and I hope everything gets settled soon.


David Berridge, 25-08-2008 - Canada

This is too soon to bring a concert when so many are hungry, homeless, and in need of medical attention. Let the urgent and practical aid arrive first, then bring in the cultural and artistic restoration to follow shortly thereafter to achieve its maximum benefit. [RNW: edited]


Tata, 23-08-2008 -

Aren't people bound to question his motives? The same question can be easily applied to the authors themselves, Jan Raes, George Bush, and many others. Such technique, especially taken together with unfounded assertions about close friendship between Valery Gergiev and Putin, is pure demagogy. Obviously, it is intended to prepare public opinion. Just in case... I wonder why Europeans try so hard to hide the truth. Not long ago, the Soviet propaganga was doing exactly the same.


Sergei, 21-08-2008 -

Just another news story that most likely won't make it to CNN and FOX News. But I bet there would be live coverage if a chief conductor of the London Symphony Orchestra was performing in Tbilisi.


Give your reaction



Name
E-mail
Hide my email address
Show my email address
URL
City
Country
Comments
  Please type in the letters/numbers in the image below in order to prevent spam.
 
Send a copy of this message to my email address
This is a moderated forum. Reactions may be edited before they appear online.