Radio Nederland Wereldomroep

English > Current Affairs > Archive by region > Europe

French nuclear diplomacy - a step too far?

By Perro de Jong

25-06-2008

France has signed a far-reaching nuclear agreement with its former colony Algeria. President Nicolas Sarkozy is committed to improving co-operation between Mediterranean countries and the European Union. However, not everyone is happy about Paris' attempts to find favour with Algeria.

'A memorandum of trust' is how French Prime Minister François Fillon described the agreement that he signed last weekend. The French prime minister was in Algiers to persuade Algerian President Abdelaziz Bouteflika to take part in the Mediterranean Union, a project that is dear to President Sarkozy's heart.

 Nuclear-power-plant
Nuclear power plant

The organisation aims to boost ties between the European Union and nations with a Mediterranean border. However, at the end of the visit, which was the first by a French premier in 22 years, president Bouteflika refused to commit himself to joining the MU. It appears that the trust built between France and its former colony doesn't extend quite so far.

Diplomatic lubricant
France sees Algeria as the key to the Islamic world and to a larger a diplomatic role for Paris. Before Paris can accomplish that however, traumas from the colonial period need to be dealt with.

The nuclear agreement is a start. France is a world leader in nuclear technology, three quarters of French energy is generated by nuclear power and President Sarkozy wants to use French nuclear know-how as a diplomatic lubricant.

Last year, the French president promised that Algeria would become the first Arab country to profit from advanced French nuclear technology. Meanwhile, Paris has announced co-operation deals with Tunisia, Jordan, the United Arab Emirates and with the former international pariah, Libya.

Dangerous game
The environmental organisation Greenpeace is very concerned about the French plans. According to Greenpeace spokesperson Frederique Marillier exporting nuclear technology for political gain is "a dangerous game".

The nuclear agreement signed by Prime Minister Fillon provides cooperation in the field of training and joint research projects. The agreement also provides the possibility of building nuclear reactors in Algeria. Paris has emphasised that the reactors will not be used for military purposes. Despite Paris's reassurances, Ms Marillier is not convinced:

"France should know from its past that developing nuclear agreements may lead to a military programme, because nuclear is always both civil and military. You know, France developed nuclear agreements with Israel, with Iran, with Iraq. And in each case there is some example of at least trying to develop a military programme."

Al-Qaeda terrorists
Even less reassuring is the fact that until very recently, a bloody civil war was raging between the Algerian government and fundamentalist Muslims. According to Prime Minister Fillon, the war is now over and Algeria is a guiding light, showing other nations how a  
Algeria-map 
moderate regime can stop fundamentalists.

Despite the war being over, 13 people were killed earlier this month in a double attack east of the capital Algiers. The target was a French man working for the French-Algerian rail network. Responsibility for the attack has been claimed by al-Qaeda in the Islamic Mahgreb.

Jean-Pierre Maulny, interim director of IRIS, the Institute for International relations in Paris, says:

"This problem is all over the region. It's difficult to say if in the future we'll have more attacks. For the moment I think it's stable enough. The problem is perhaps for the future, for the ten or fifteen years beyond. Because we have the whole question future terrorism, which is a political problem to be resolved by the countries in the Mahreb."

Neo-colonial adder
Frederique Marillier says political reasons aren't enough to explain why France is taking such enormous risks. She believes that there is a neo-colonial adder in the grass:

"There is a part of the agreement dealing with mining prospection. As you know, there is a big tension at the moment on the uranium market due to development in China and India. There is a clear new development of mining, and AREVA is looking for a new country to develop mining. So it's also a direct interest for the nuclear industry."

Ironically enough, Algeria served as Paris's nuclear testing ground in the past. France carried out 13 nuclear tests in the Algerian Sahara in the early 1960s. But the tests were not

Al-Qaeda
  Al-Qaeda destruction 

a glowing recommendation for nuclear power as a number of Algerians became ill as a result of the tests.

Earlier this year, Paris promised to start a new investigation into that particular black page in the French-Algerian joint history. The promise thawed the chill in bilateral relations and prepared the way for a new nuclear chapter. It remains to be seen whether the risks will be smaller this time round.

 

Tags: Algeria, European Union, Mediterranean, nuclear technology, President Nicolas Sarkozy

Reaction(s):


Jorge Picabea, 01-07-2008 - USA

Let Sarkozy do what he wants! The US and Greenpeace are in no position to tell Europeans what to do. The rapid decline of the US society and economy, despite a tremendous head start after WWII, shows that American values and procedures are wrong. The world is finding out about the true character of America, and in doing so, the US loses credibility. We should learn from France!


Dick Udell, 29-06-2008 - USA

Yes indeed, a very serious and dangerous game, a real 'can of worms'! There are many, many assurances needed here and also many future questions answered. President Sarkozy needs to be very aware of this before he proceeds in this direction!


sandra, 26-06-2008 - nederlands

It seems like Sarkozy has a progressive Identity complex, and little man syndrome. A mixed multicultural background himself that came to France as poor immigrant when he was a small child, he is playing a very dangerous game with world powers. I recall in a not so distant past a person called Hitler who had very much some of these ideas that Sarkozy had with his hunger for power and control. We all know what happened to Germany and Hitler's cowardly suicide act. Just remember Mr. Sarkozy, India, Russia and China are fast approaching superpower status and have far more resources to prove that they do not need to answer to the West. They may one day be in a position to return the favour when the West falls and needs a helping hand - but will they shut the door on the Western nations?


Vera Gottlieb, 25-06-2008 - Germany

So why all this commotion about Iran when Western nations continue to sell nuclear capabilities around the world.


Give your reaction



Name
E-mail
Hide my email address
Show my email address
URL
City
Country
Comments
  Please type in the letters/numbers in the image below in order to prevent spam.
 
Send a copy of this message to my email address
This is a moderated forum. Reactions may be edited before they appear online.