Radio Nederland Wereldomroep

English > Current Affairs

Whose anti-immigrant rhetoric is the toughest?

By political editor Rutger van Santen*

12-11-2007

VVD MP Henk KampTough measures to tackle problem youths from migrant backgrounds, DNA tests to prevent marriages between cousins, a ban on all clothing that conceals the face, a ban on broadcasting the call to prayer.

Tough language heralded the return of VVD (conservative) MP Henk Kamp to the lower house of the Dutch parliament.

His message is aimed at voters; they don't have to defect to Geert Wilders or Rita Verdonk, they can stay in the VVD for tough anti-Islam rhetoric and anti-immigrant policies.

Some 30 percent of the Dutch electorate no longer vote along traditional lines. These swing voters are not influenced by principles or social economic questions; they are influenced by issues about which they are woefully ignorant but are the subject of tough talk by politicians.

Political opportunism
Despite the fact that the majority of Dutch people have had nothing to do with crime, it was the most important theme during the elections a few years ago. The development has led to the steady increase of opportunism on the Dutch political landscape.

The developments also led to Geert Wilders' right-wing Party for Freedom, PVV, winning nine seats at the last election. Throughout the election campaign, the PVV hammered home its hard-line against foreigners, specifically Islamic foreigners, and the tactic paid off in parliamentary seats. The former immigration and integration minister Rita Verdonk, currently leading a one-person party in parliament, has also been beating the anti-immigrant drum. With her tough immigration policies and anti-immigrant rhetoric, Ms Verdonk has created an image that the latest opinion polls suggest could win as many as 18 seats in the next election.

Damage to the conservatives
These developments have to a certain degree damaged the conservative VVD party. It's no coincidence that both Mr Wilders and Ms Verdonk are former members of the party. It would be easy for party leader Mark Rutte to borrow their rhetoric for his party's policies on the same issues, but he and his closest advisers have decided not to follow that course. They say they are determined to formulate policies in line with their own conservative values and ideals, and not to give in to opportunism.

Henk Kamp's return is something of a godsend to the VVD. A former defence minister, he was extremely popular both with the troops and the electorate, and is now the party's immigration affairs and Islam spokesperson. He has been absent from The Hague for the last six months due to knee surgery. He used his recovery period to write a 'document of basic principles on sensitive issues'. Although the document does not contain a single new idea or proposal, it does give the illusion that the VVD is back in control and knows what its values and ideals are.

Kamp's proposals
Mr Kamp released his proposals on immigration and integration at the weekend. They include actively tracking down and deporting all illegal aliens, banning mosques from broadcasting the call to prayer over loudspeakers, and stricter regulations governing import brides. The document also calls for dual passport holders aged 18 or older who become involved in criminal activity to be stripped of their Dutch nationality, a ban on all clothing that conceals the face, and faster evaluation - and eventually faster deportation - of asylum seekers.

There's nothing new in the plans but Mr Kamp's proposals could help the party to win back support that has drifted towards the more populist camps.

Still popular, but out of power
Henk Kamp's document is relatively short but the tone is tough and the author is still popular. He was, as he put it, "careful to remain within the bounds of decency". In a departure from the rhetoric of Mr Wilders and Ms Verdonk, Mr Kamp also wrote, "discrimination is just as bad as radicalisation."

The onlooker shouldn't be fooled into thinking that the 'Kamp Document'' has changed Dutch policies on immigration, immigrant affairs and Islam. The VVD, the PVV and Rita Verdonk are all on the opposition benches. They can scream as much as they like but the ruling coalition, supported by the left-wing opposition, is sure to follow its extremely moderate course. Despite his popularity, Henk Kamp can do nothing about it.

* RNW translation (jc)

Tags: conservative, Dutch, Henk Kamp, immigration, parliament, Party for Freedom, PVV, VVD

Reaction(s):


will, ontariopioneer@yahoo.ca, 11-12-2007 - Singapore

It's up to the Dutch. Do they want their country swamped and their own folk reduced to a sharia-ruled minority? Wilders is a good guy!


Peter, 24-11-2007 - The Netherlands

The VVD is not wat Sandra discribes. Please do not forget that in the Netherlands, we do NOT have a right wing conservative party. A truly conservative party stands for - small governemnt - low taxes (for everybody) - zero tolerance for criminals The VVD is more of a 'middle-party' with a few rightwing ideas. Greetings from the Netherlands


Sandra, 15-11-2007 - Nederlands

I almost forgot. Let me add that it is not a bad idea to strip Dutch citizenship from criminals that have dual citizenship.


Marc, 13-11-2007 - RSA

I wish this returnee to the Dutch political landscape good luck with his proposals. His desire to wrest back some modicum of Dutch values in Holland (which would help certain districts back from the edge of de-civilisation) should be supported. Terms such as 'global village' and 'cultural melting pots', or worse, 'minority renaissance' are just liberal verbiage for acknowledging the slippery slide into a morass of community degeneration. A crime-ridden ghetto for the hapless taxpayer to get invoiced for.


Sandra, 13-11-2007 - Nederlands

VVD is only for the rich, and they are responsible for the rich getting richer, the poor getting poorer. Overtaxing the middle class and poor while giving big tax breaks to the rich and powerful business owners. The VVD is also responsible for the overpriced medical insurance coverages that affect the middle class and the poor. So all this anti-immigration rhetoric is getting on people's nerves. We have enough anti-immigration politicians, now why doesn't someone come up with solutions to the poverty that is affecting the Dutch people and lower medical coverage so that the Dutch people have something to spend out of their wages instead of all on bills every month!


terence wilson, 13-11-2007 - United states of America

Perhaps it should be discussed just what Dutch internationalists have in mind for Holland before focusing on the immigrant(s). When people who consider themselves 'international citizens' before national ones, what can be expected of them on immigration? Finance? Or the military? The fish stinks at the head-start there. Islam, with its definate rules and morals, can fill a void left by secularization, or relativist culture; if truth is considered relative, so are national borders.


Give your reaction



Name
E-mail
Hide my email address
Show my email address
URL
City
Country
Comments
  Please type in the letters/numbers in the image below in order to prevent spam.
 
Send a copy of this message to my email address
This is a moderated forum. Reactions may be edited before they appear online.